I am a long time admirer of Shelby's creations, so when my office needed cupcakes for someone's event I was quick to recommend her. Naturally the cupcakes were a hit, and everyone wanted to know what else she had to offer. I recommended her butter tarts, and we placed another order. "Treat day" is now a thing, and we will always look forward to placing our order with her, not just because her creations are delicious, but because she is so wonderfully accommodating and so willing to please. The last order we place, she actually individually packaged people's tarts and put their names on the boxes. We are super impressed and I have no doubt anyone else would be too. Thank you Shelby! -Eva

The BEST butter tart I have ever had ! Absolutely delicious and full of flavor :) I am a competitive cyclist. I ride 10,000km / year. I have a butter tart in every city/town I stop while riding southwestern Ontario. My friends and I rode from Toronto to Paris for Grilled Cheese in Wincey Market. I bought a butter tart from Shelby @ Sugar & Spice; I should have gotten two, it was the best butter I ever had :) - Charles

"The best buttertarts ever! Amazing! And banana cream pie.... So wonderful..."


"Thank you so much for the gingerbread house kit! My son actually managed to decorate the house before he ate too much of the candy and the gingerbread is delicious. I won't have time to cook a whole batch of gingerbread this year but still wanted something homemade tasting and that was exactly what we got. I like to bake a lot so am very picky about where I buy my baked goods and everyone was right your stuff is amazing! We will definitely be repeat customers!" -Lynn

"My son's birthday cake was PERFECT!! The toys were worked into the design flawlessly and everyone loved it. Thanks so much. I'll definitely be back."               -Amanda

"Had a surprise birthday cake made for my boyfriend & she went beyond my expectations! I sent her an image of the whiskey barrel I wanted and she replicated it, but in my opinion even made it better by looking more authentic. Once you get overall beauty of the appearance you slice the cake and that's when it really takes your breathe away! It was moist and tasted amazing, I had only compliments from those who had a slice! I couldn't be more thankful and will most def be back ...."-Nicole

"Shelby did a beautiful job with my wedding cake as well as my baby shower cake. She makes amazing treats and I wouldn't go anywhere else! Very easy to work with and makes your ideas come to life. A perfectionist when it comes to her designs! Shelby takes the time and it shows."-Annette

"I have tried quite a selection of yummy goodies from Sugar & Spice Bakery and I have to say that there is no need to go anywhere else. Shelby's stuff is incredible. I will say this, if you like cheesecake you will absolutely love her cinnamon bun cheesecake. It is so delicious. It is also nice that Shelby is such a sweetheart she is very friendly and very accommodating. She will put her heart and soul in to everything she makes. She made our gender reveal cake for us with our third baby and it was absolutely perfect! So glad we had her do it. I have never been disappointed with anything Shelby has made. She does only the best!!! Thanks Shelby for always making such incredible looking and delicious tasting goodies I am one satisfied customer! I will always go to her every time."-Sheri 

"My husband ordered a strawberry birthday cake for my birthday and it was outstanding. We could not believe how well the natural strawberry flavour and fragrance came through. Awesome job, we are trying to think of more events to celebrate just to have more cake."-Amber 

"I have been the happy recipient of Shelby's baked goods for better than 20 years now. I can honestly say I have never been disappointed in her creations. I can provide this honest feedback not because I am her Dad but because I have been made to pay for the baked goods I have ordered. Her Mother will not let her give me free goodies. That alone should give me cause to grumble but I can not bring myself to do that because her creations are not only delightful for the eyes but delicious to the taste buds."- John 

"Cake was delicious" - John

Send us your feedback